“Computer says no” should never be the final word

A picture containing text

Description automatically generated

MR RICK WILSON MP
FEDERAL MEMBER FOR O’CONNOR

 

10th November 2026

OPINION: “Computer says no” should never be the final word

"Computer says no" was the punchline of a popular British comedy sketch, where a frustrated customer was left at the mercy of a computer-generated decision.

It was satire. But seniors across regional Australia could be forgiven for wondering whether the Albanese Government has turned it into public policy.

Since November 2025, a qualified aged care assessor can no longer decide how much support an older Australian receives and how long they wait for it. Instead, those decisions are made by a computer algorithm, with no ability for assessors to override the outcome when they believe it is wrong.

Whether you live in Albany, Esperance, Manjimup, Narrogin, Katanning or Kalgoorlie-Boulder, most older Australians share the same wish: to stay in their own home, surrounded by family, friends and the community they know, for as long as possible.

For some, that means a few hours of support each week. For others, it could be home modifications, mobility assistance or help with everyday tasks.

Earlier this year, I wrote to constituents aged 65 and over seeking their views on Labor's proposed private health insurance rebate cuts – which was ultimately defeated in the Senate, but Labor has vowed to put it before the Senate again. The response was overwhelming.

People were worried about being punished for maintaining private cover and concerned about yet another decision that would make healthcare less accessible and more expensive, a reality already faced by many in regional Western Australia.

Those responses reflected a broader frustration that I hear right across O'Connor. Too often, under Labor, there has always been a sense in regional Australia that decisions are being made in distant offices by people who don't understand the realities of life in the bush.

That is exactly why Labor's aged care assessment algorithm is so concerning.

These are deeply personal circumstances. They cannot be reduced to a formula or calculated by an algorithm sitting in a government system.

A qualified assessor sitting with a senior in Bridgetown, Gnowangerup or Lake Grace can see things a computer never will. They can understand the challenges of living alone, the support available from family, the realities of distance in regional communities and the practical barriers that affect day-to-day life.

Yet under Labor's system, assessors have been stripped of the ability to overrule the computer, even when they believe the outcome is wrong.

That is why Coalition Members and Senators worked with the crossbench to pass legislation restoring human override of aged care assessments. Unfortunately, Labor has refused to bring that legislation on for a vote in the House of Representatives.

Now the Commonwealth Ombudsman has delivered a damning assessment of the Government's approach.

The Ombudsman found the system was "unreasonable" and that a reasonable person could lack confidence that it was fair and consistent. More concerning still, assessors were prohibited from overriding the computer's decisions, even when they considered them to be clinically inappropriate.

A trained professional can identify that a decision is wrong, understand why it is wrong and know what support a person needs, yet still be prevented from fixing the problem because a computer has made the final call.

The Ombudsman recommended restoring human oversight, yet Labor continues to defend a system that places greater faith in an algorithm than in the judgement of qualified professionals.

Older Australians have worked hard, paid their taxes and helped build the communities we call home. They deserve better than being reduced to a computer-generated score.

When it comes to aged care, technology should support professional judgement, not replace it. Because when your health, independence and quality of life are on the line, "computer says no" should never be the final word.

ENDS

Media contact:
Reuben Keyser
Communications and Community Engagement Adviser
[email protected]
(08) 9842 2777
0455 125 035

Share this:

Sign in if you'd like new recruits to be credited to you.